Comments on: Why Star Trek Discovery is Garbage

By: Manuel Moda

Manuel Moda — Fri, 01 Mar 2024 10:35:55 +0000

The sense of really TV show exisits in Star Trek. The character of Michael Burnham take decisions without explaining. Your review is really helpful for Star Trek lovers.

By: The First Officer

The First Officer — Thu, 28 Dec 2023 04:14:43 +0000

Now finishing season 3. Wow…I just can’t stand it, but keep hoping it will have improve. The main character, Michael Burnam, is an emotional wreck. She is a Commander but was dressed down an Ensign? Do the writers have the first clue about chain of command? And this Ensign, Tilley, has to be the most annoying characters in the entire franchise. A character with diarrhea of the mouth and the emotional maturity of a 12 year old Valley Girl. Her crewmates roll their eyes, while I want to duct tape her mouth shut. And why she is the focus of so much attention is beyond my ken.
There isn’t a single likeable character in the entire crew. And the only one with any spine and spunk is the Terran Empress.

The overwrought emotional melodrama is both vapid and exhausting. I don’t want people brought back from the dead. I don’t care about their relationships or gender roles. I don’t care about pronouns. I don’t care about the interpersonal relationships of crewmates. Just stop. Plus all the weeping and crying and hysteria from a command officer? Please. It’s ridiculous. They all seem to be in desperate need of psychiatric re-evaluation.
Having diverse characters is a good thing. But when it becomes an in your face agenda I tune out. These characters are supposed to be professional military academy graduates, not burbling, emotionally untethered, cry-babies. I do not read or watch SF to be deluged with interpersonal relationships, blithering emotionally overwrought command officers who regularly cry and cannot make the hard call, or put their own personal feelings ahead of the safety of the crew.
Someone posted on Reddit that the problem with Discovery is that the writers seem to hate Star Trek. Truer words.

By: Uprising Review | » Star Trek Discovery Still Sucks And CBS Won’t Learn Their Lesson

Sun, 22 Oct 2023 04:49:36 +0000

[…] You can find my first article on Star Trek Discovery here. […]

By: Bick Dick Rick

Bick Dick Rick — Sun, 22 Oct 2023 04:23:51 +0000

i cannot stand this show. thanks for the great review. saved me from watching any further seasons

By: JA

JA — Thu, 21 Sep 2023 18:58:20 +0000

Agreed with most points above. My other thing is every single show and plot Michael always and almost solely solves the issues. Balance the characters and knowledge. How come she knows more about science and medical issues than the science officer or medical. Hard to relate when only one character is propped up to make others look irrelevant. Even when they try to build a character in the show always comes back to her shadowing everyone. Watched so of them and always comes back to the same thing Michael can solve everything and the only one who can save everyone and humanity. Really??? Plus she is not really a great actor, actually many others on the show are better.

By: star trek jacket

star trek jacket — Wed, 06 Sep 2023 07:47:18 +0000

I can understand your disappointment with the show’s character development and plot. Quality storytelling is crucial. It’s good to know you found the actress playing the captain compelling, though. Constructive criticism can help the series improve.

By: MAGA Tears

MAGA Tears — Sun, 03 Sep 2023 12:34:19 +0000

LOL. What a bunch of whiny babies. TOS was all about breaking down barriers and overthrowing the bigoted social order of the day and giving the under represented in society a voice and role models.

Well it’s 2023 and all the whiny MAGA tards are doing the same BS that people in the 60s did when Kirk kissed Uhura.

You guys are the problem, not Star Trek Discovery, which is a kick ass show!

LOL MAGA Tears!!!

By: Carsten

Carsten — Mon, 07 Aug 2023 19:10:25 +0000

In reply to John.

You dont Know what You are taliknig about. Star Trek Discovery is THE VERY BEST of all Star Trek series. – Its just take some time to ajust to a updated Star Trek. – And about the gay couple… – Well I Dislike That every tv-serie and movie has at least one gay or lesbian couple.. Because it is a overrepresentation.. — But in STD I did see the good acting and the love and sweetness among those to guys. – Its not ugly at all…. – And for all You STD haters, You can celebrate – After season 5 There will be no more. — And Thats not cause its bad — it is because PARAMOUNT cant pay for all the expensive effects… ——- And dont forget .. While talking about BAD STAR TREK… I can mention a few……. STRANGE NEW WORLDS sucks! – The whole last episode, all of the crew did sing songs non stop. WTF??? — Are they TOTALLY MAAD?? — And Star Trek Deep Space Nine is also TERRIBLE! —- The Next Generation is hardly worth to watch in 2023. — Even thou i loved it in 1980s !

By: DarthBK

DarthBK — Fri, 30 Jun 2023 16:48:06 +0000

I wonder if any of the writers involved are holding their signs the highest in the current strike

By: cardo

cardo — Thu, 01 Jun 2023 03:35:17 +0000

In reply to Dennis. black alert made me quit watching